When You Make Someone Wrong – Part 1
Posted on 07. Apr, 2011 by Shawn Murphy in 1 Leadership, People & Change
Let’s continue the message this week around connecting and communicating. I want to dig deeper and explore the nasty barrier that prevents connection and communication – the sinister need to make people wrong.
I’m familiar with the nasty need to make another person wrong. For me there are red flags when I’ve ventured into this dangerous territory, and I share them below. But first let me share why I believe making someone wrong is ugly.
1. The moment I make another person wrong, I’ve torn them away from the conversation. A barrier now exists and the quality of the interaction is compromised.
2. The ability to get to an outcome that leaves everyone satisfied is highly unlikely. Making someone wrong wastes everyone’s time.
Unfortunately I have many red flags signaling when I’ve tread into a collaboration-killer zone. Because I have much to say on this topic, I’ll introduce them over a small series of posts. Any one or more of these has dashed the possibility of truly connecting with others. And communication….well, it’s lost too.
- Should Language. The moment I start “shoulding” all over the place, I’ve damaged the connection. “You shouldn’t be so sensitive.” “You should be more commanding in meetings.” “You’re the leader, you should know what to do.” Though the point I’m attempting to make may be rooted in truth, the delivery sucks. When “should” is involved in your language, the implication is that the person is wrong, and defenses are up. What does it matter that you may be right? Aren’t we here to help each other be successful? Making someone wrong diminishes success and exacerbates problems.
Treatment: I’ve learned to ask questions. “How do you think the meeting went?” The question lets the person articulate his perspective. Most people are harder on themselves and will know where mistakes were made before recognizing the good parts. Let them be hard on themselves. Then follow up with, “I noticed those, too, but I also saw you do some damn good work in there.” Follow it up with some positive observations.
Businesses – big and small – have gone through some tough times. Let’s help each other out by not getting “juiced” by the opportunity to point out another person’s flaws by making them wrong. We’re all licking our wounds. Lend a hand by dropping the Should Language.
What would you add to this conversation about making someone wrong?





Susan Mazza
07. Apr, 2011
I love how straight you are Shawn! And I love this phrase “collaboration-killer zone”
There is only one thing more satisfying than making others wrong…being right! In our need to and/or satisfaction with being right we can actually completely miss that our being right has left someone else feeling made wrong and shut down all possibility of effective communication. So a red flag for me is when I notice I am being righteous – it’s a clear indication that I am not listening at best and causing harm to another at worst.
Shawn Murphy
07. Apr, 2011
Hey Susan,
Boy oh boy, righteousness is definitely a good one. I know it’s ugly presence, unfortunately.
Shawn
Thomas McDaniels
07. Apr, 2011
Great post Shawn and great content. Love this kind of stuff. Hope we all remember when are emotions on high. Love the development stuff!
Shawn Murphy
08. Apr, 2011
Hi Thomas,
And if we don’t remember the message in NOT making others wrong when emotions are high, hopefully when they subside the realization sets in.
I appreciate your support Thomas.
Shawn